17 November 2026
The Government must ensure that its plans for Force mergers deliver significant benefits for policing without proving too costly for council tax payers, according to the chair of West Midlands Police Federation.
Jess Davies was responding to reports in Monday’s Telegraph that the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners (APCC) was warning Labour’s plans for police reform could mean millions of households would face paying higher council tax.
“The Police Federation has already issued its own warnings on the crisis in the police service,” says Jess, “Years of under-investment have brought us to the point where we are struggling to retain officers and we are seeing a revolving door type effect through which as fast as we welcome new recruits we are losing some of our more experienced officers.
“It really should come as no surprise that officers are leaving in their droves. Their pay has fallen by 21 per cent in real terms since 2010, with a third of officers struggling to afford food, rent and heating. At the same time, the number of assaults on officers has soared. Latest statistics show around 86 officers are attacked every single day.
“Police officers are also increasingly finding their mental health is suffering and policing is now the profession with the highest rates of mental health related sickness.
“Given these factors and the day to day challenges brought by the realities of modern-day policing, our members are seeking new careers that bring better pay and conditions without the demands and dangers of being a police officer.”
In acknowledging the current crisis in the police service, Jess wants to see the Government prioritise reforming the way in which forces are funded and also ensuring that the mechanism for determining police pay is truly independent.
“There is a fundamental flaw in the current police funding formula and this needs to be tackled as a matter of urgency, particularly in light of the plans for Force mergers,” she explains.
“We cannot be expected to provide the 21st century policing services our communities deserve with a 20th century funding model. It is 2026 not 1996.
“I think the Government needs to give really careful consideration to its plans for force mergers, because while we accept police reform is necessary, I am not entirely convinced the benefits of these proposed mergers will really justify the potential costs, particularly at a time when householders are already seeing their outgoings increase due to the cost of living crisis.
“The Government must ensure that its plans for Force mergers deliver significant benefits for policing without proving too costly for council tax payers.”
Earlier this year, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, the Labour MP for Birmingham Ladywood, set out plans to reduce the number of police forces across England and Wales from 43 to as few as 9.
The APCC, ahead of its conference this week, has predicted this could mean people living in Band D properties could pay as much as £70 extra a year for policing, according to the Telegraph.
More than 30 PCCs, including members of Labour, the Conservatives and Reform as well as independents, have written to the Prime Minister expressing their concerns about mergers saying ‘enormous regional super-forces’ were contrary to Andy Burnham’s drive towards devolution, and risked weakening democratic accountability while also disrupting crime-fighting.
Analysis by the Telegraph suggests that people in the West Midlands could see the second steepest increase in council tax, £36 a year, on top of an expected £14 a year increase in the precept.
Under the merger plans, some other Band D households could see reductions in their council tax bills, according to the APCC.