Police widows await court ruling on ‘unjust’ pension rule

5 October 2021

Campaigners have reached a critical point in their legal bid to overturn a rule which they say discriminates against police widows and widowers.

Regulation C9 of the Police Pension Regulations 1987 prevents the widow/widower of a police officer from receiving their loved one’s police pension if they remarry or cohabit.

Campaigners have long argued that Regulation C9 discriminates against widows and widowers and breaches their human rights, as they are unable to remarry or cohabit without financial penalty, and those who have already remarried or moved in with a partner continue to endure financial losses.

Three individuals who are challenging the rule, with support from the National Association of Retired Police Officers (NARPO) and the Police Federation, presented documents to the High Court in Manchester in August.

His Honour Judge Sephton QC determined that their claims should be allowed to proceed to a full and final hearing, which will take place on 5 -6 April 2022.

West Midlands Police widow Kate Hall said: “It gives me hope to hear Judge Sephton acknowledge that there should be a full judicial review - during which evidence can be presented that Regulation C9 remains discriminatory, unfair and a breach of our fundamental human rights.

“Regulation C9 is responsible for widespread misery. Finally after many years of campaigning, there is the possibility that that misery may finally be coming to an end. Finally we may be able to lead a normal life. I don’t think that is too much to ask.”

Kate’s husband, Colin, died on 29 November 1987 when he was 40-years-old. A police dog handler, he collapsed and died after helping quell a disturbance at a block of flats.

The Federation, NARPO and the legal team will continue to work with the lead applicants to bring their legal claim to the High Court.